Archives » Robbie Cleary

Dumbarton 0 – 5 Annan Athletic

SPFL Tier 4, The Rock, 14/11/26

Shambles.

Complete. Utter. Shambles.

Why did I put myself through this? They were – are – bottom of the league and had lost six in a row. A win would have put us well ahead of them. As it is now they’ll have us in their sights.

Okay we were missing big Ali Omar at the back since he was off playing for Somalia but the curious thing is that we started well, creating three great opportunities. However Tony Wallace hit a weak shot, Robbie Cleary took a heavy touch, both allowing the keeper to save. Then Tony Wallace had a one-on-one right in the centre of the goal but didn’t manage to place it either side of the keeper.

Then the wheels fell off.

Tommy Robson failed to clear in the box, trying to be too clever, and the attacker nicked it off him, Owen Hartington passed the ball to space in the box where the nearest player was one of Annan’s who was left with just Mason Munn to beat, for the third the defence got sucked towards the ball leaving a man totally free on the left. The fourth came after a not well cleared corner with the eventual crosser not being shut down and the scorer allowed a free header in the box, the fifth was a result of another badly cleared corner followed by a poor defensive header straight to the head of the scorer.

When you give the ball directly to the opposition in your own box three times in the one game and continue to defend woefully you won’t win anything.

The players need to take a good long hard look at themselves.

The new manager,  when he’s appointed, has some job on.

Dumbarton 2-1 Forfar Athletic

SPFL Tier 4, The Rock, 04/10/26.

Another win and another strange one.

We set up with a back three – of Tom Lang, new loan defender Chris McKenna and Ali Omar on the left of the three.

But we were absolutely woeful in the first half. Despite nominally having five bodies in that area they were strolling through our midfield as if it wasn’t there (well, it wasn’t,) and Josh Todd gave away more balls than he held on to.

Their goal was a case in point: no resistance whatever given in the build-up and the guy who crossed it given oodles of space to do so. Not to mention the all but free header. Once again we had not enough of the ball. Most of their other efforts were from comfortable range with Mason Munn’s positioning in goal making his saves comfortable. We did manage to make their keeper make two good saves, though. One close-in block when Josiah Sowa was played in and the other a long range pile driver by Owen Hartington, heading for the top corner before being pushed away for a corner.

Not much changed early in the second half. Oddly we equalised while Josiah Sowa was off the park. He’d had his boot trodden off and was forced off to replace it. Scott Honeyman retrieved the ball in midfield from a miscontrol by a Forfar defender and sent Mikey Doyle down the right. His cross was powered in by Robbie Cleary.

Two minutes later we were in the lead. A ball played up to Leighton McIntosh evaded the defender and he scurried to the bye-line and crossed. The keeper spilled it but Owen Hartington had to turn back to pick it up before the nearest defender. He swivelled on it and wrongfooted the keeper to place it in the corner.

We ended the game with effectively no forwards on as Robbie Cleary and Leighton McIntosh were both withdrawn with ten minutes to go. I thought that might cost us. One day it will.

This was a win achieved not by any tactical acumen – the set up wasn’t right – but by the players doing what they could to overcome that.

Dumbarton 3-0 The Spartans

SPFL Tier 4, The Rock, 19/09/26.

Football is a funny game. On the face of it this was a comprehensive win, yet at no time during it did it feel that way. Yes we scored early, a fine move down the right with Robbie Cleary and Mikey Doyle exchanging passes before Doyle crossed for Deryn Lang to get in front of his defender and smash the ball in. But the BBC statistics show we had only 31% possession over the whole game.

Mind you new loan keeper Mason Munn barely had a save to make, certainly not from a threatening shot. It has to be said he looked assured enough, a contrast to Harry Broun who has now left the club again after only rejoining a couple of weeks ago.

The formation was strange again, selection bingo once more at work. The choice of fielding Leighton McIntosh in midfield seemed odd but someone on Pie and Bovril opined he had been given a man marking job. Another returnee, Tom Lang, helped to shore up the defence. While Spartans moved the ball about – and looked as if they had played together before – they seemed to lack penetration.

We did little of attacking note in the first half after we scored and thoughts of last week’s second half capitulation against Stranraer were never far away.

The second goal changed things and, like two weeks ago against Elgin, there was an air of freakishness  about it, Robbie Cleary’s corner bouncing off a defender and going in off the post. The players celebrated it big style.

I thought to myself, though, how on Earth are we winning this 2-0? Apart from the goals their keeper hadn’t a save to make. It was that kind of game.

Spartans had to come at us a bit more after that and despite our last two substitutions smacking of a defensive mindset we managed up the park a few times. Josiah Sowa, who had come on midway through the half, showed just how good he can be at exploiting space when he cut in from the left and pinged a beauty in for no 3 in stoppage time.

We’re now joint second bottom, or alternatively, joint sixth and only two points off the promotion play-off spots. No chickens being counted here though. I think the players won this despite the manager, not because of him.

Dumbarton 2-1 Elgin City

SPFL Tier 4, The Rock, 5/9/26

A win is welcome but I couldn’t say we really deserved it.

The game was very bitty but while Elgin looked good at times with passing and movement they didn’t threaten our goal at all first half. They were the better team footballing wise, though. At least they looked as if they had a clue what they were supposed to be doing, whereas, of course we didn’t. In particular our set-piece delivery continues to be atrocious.

At least we seem to have dispensed with the playing out from the back rubbish. Returned keeper Harry Broun, brought back to the club due to Aidan Rice being injured playing for his parent club, maybe doesn’t suit that, but who knows?

It was selection bingo all over again and we seemed to be back to the 3-5-2 which served us well enough towards the end of last season, but with Leighton McIntosh dropped for new boy Robbie Cleary who partnered Deryn Lang up front.

Josiah Sowa was agreeably tenacious at left wing-back but it nullified his attacking qualities.

In effect our first was a one man effort by Robbie Cleary and the second not something you’ll see very often.

Ali Omar took a free-kick from inside our half. At first I thought, “He’s overhit that, what was he thinking?” then, “Where’s the keeper? It might beat him,” then “It’s going in!” then, “Was it a direct free-kick?” which of course it was.

We stood off them too much after the subsequent substitutions, our midfield disappearing, and of course the inevitable happened.  We’d managed to survive the one minute off the field for a treated injury but were still re-organising back with eleven men when they scored. Too easily.

The performance wasn’t great – too many misplaced passes, no creativity, no penetration – but sometimes you win when you don’t deserve to. And you can’t rely on a worldie like we saw today.

I’m sure a different manager could get more out of these players. They’re good enough; they just need better direction.

free hit counter script